Strupp & BrummCosmetic & Restorative Dentistry

Choosing a Dentist · 7 min read

How to Choose a Cosmetic Dentist: 7 Credentials That Actually Matter

Any dentist can call themselves a cosmetic dentist. Here are the seven credentials and signals that distinguish genuine cosmetic expertise from marketing.

By Strupp & Brumm · April 15, 2026

There is no legal restriction on calling yourself a "cosmetic dentist" in the United States. A general dentist who places occasional veneers can use the term — and most do. That's why choosing a cosmetic dentist on the strength of marketing alone is risky.

Here are seven credentials and signals that actually tell you whether a dentist has the demonstrated skill to handle your case.

1. AACD Accreditation or Fellowship

The single strongest signal. Accreditation in the American Academy of Cosmetic Dentistry requires the dentist to pass a written examination, submit five peer-reviewed clinical cases, and pass an oral examination. Fewer than 400 dentists in the world hold AACD Accreditation. Fellowship — the highest level — is held by fewer than 100. Learn what AACD Accreditation actually requires →

2. In-house dental laboratory

About 3% of dental offices have an in-house laboratory. An in-house lab means the ceramists who fabricate your restorations work in the same building as the dentist — collaborating in real time on shade, shape, and fit. This matters most on complex cases where aesthetic precision is critical.

3. Before-and-after gallery of *their own* work

Good cosmetic dentists show their work. Look for a gallery with dozens of cases, ideally with variety (single-tooth bonding, full smile designs, complex reconstructions) and consistent visual style. Stock photos or "patient results may vary" boilerplate over a thin gallery is a warning sign.

4. Long-term patient relationships

Ask how many of the practice's patients have been with them for 10+ years. Great cosmetic dentists have multi-generational families in their patient base — parents, adult children, grandchildren all on the schedule. That's impossible to fake.

5. Continuing education leadership

Dentists who teach cosmetic dentistry to other dentists tend to be the best at practicing it. Look for dentists named to Dentistry Today's Leaders in Continuing Education list, or who lecture at major dental conferences. A dentist who has taught 45,000 of their peers has, by definition, clinical depth most practices don't.

6. Peer referrals

Great cosmetic dentists see other dentists as patients. If you can find out whether a practice counts other dentists — and their families — among its patients, that tells you more than any review ever will. Dentists know who does good work.

7. Transparency about cost and limits

Watch for honesty about what the treatment cannot do. A dentist who tells you they'd recommend whitening or bonding instead of the veneer case you asked about is a dentist prioritizing the right result, not the larger invoice. That honesty is a credential in itself.

What doesn't matter (as much as you'd think)

  • Instagram follower count. Unrelated to clinical skill.
  • "Best of [city]" awards from pay-to-play directories. Unrelated to clinical skill.
  • Sleek website. Entirely unrelated to clinical skill. (Ours happens to be nice. Many great practices have ugly websites.)

Putting it together

No single credential makes a great cosmetic dentist. The combination — Accreditation or Fellowship + in-house lab + a deep gallery + long-term patients + teaching other dentists — is what to look for. If you can find a practice that checks most of these boxes within reasonable distance of where you live (or travel to), you are probably in the right hands.

If you are searching for a practice that fits this profile in the Tampa Bay area, we'd welcome the chance to introduce ourselves.

Have a question about your smile?

We welcome the opportunity to meet at our Clearwater office. Dr. Strupp and Dr. Brumm will answer your questions honestly — and tell you if we think another option is better for you.

CallConsult